Shepherd's pie (or cottage pie) and acid reflux: is it safe to eat?
Pastel de carne y papa (shepherd's pie)
It is best avoided in the healing phase. In maintenance it is allowed in moderation. Main factors: high fat, raw onion / garlic. Its pH is 5.1–6.9 (estimated).
Shepherd's pie uses lamb and cottage pie uses beef; both have a mashed-potato top and a little tomato or Worcestershire in the gravy.
Why
High fat Grade B
Fatty meals slow stomach emptying and increase transient relaxations of the lower esophageal sphincter, the valve that keeps stomach contents down.
Evidence: Castell DO, et al · Lechien JR, et al · Heidarzadeh-Esfahani N, et al
Raw onion / garlic Grade C
In a controlled pH-probe study, raw onion increased reflux episodes and heartburn in people with heartburn, but not in healthy people. Many clinicians find cooked onion and garlic better tolerated, although that has not been studied.
Evidence: Allen ML, et al
Recommended alternatives for the healing phase:
pH source: Estimated from main ingredients (beef 5.4-5.8 (MLA/CSIRO; red-meat proxy for lamb), mashed potatoes 5.10 (FDA), cooked carrots 5.58-6.03 (FDA), cooked peas 6.22-6.88 (FDA), onions 5.32-5.85 (FDA)); no published measurement of this item.
Similar foods
- Meatloaf with ketchup glaze
- Aloo gobi (potato and cauliflower)
- Beef ravioli, canned (Chef Boyardee)
- Bobotie (South African curried mince with egg topping)
- Börek (cheese or spinach phyllo pie)
- Caldereta (Filipino tomato meat stew)
- Canned chili with beans
- Corned beef hash, canned
What are reflux and silent reflux? Read the full explanation →
Educational content; not a substitute for medical evaluation. See a doctor if you have hoarseness lasting more than 3 weeks, difficulty or pain swallowing, unexplained weight loss, vomiting blood or black stools. If you have chest pain, seek emergency care.
Reviewed by Laureano A. Giráldez Rodríguez, MD, FACS · Voice and Swallowing Center of Puerto Rico · Updated: 2026-11-12